'15 Shimano Aldebaran take down and testing.

This is the place to talk shop about all the enthusiast and import tackle for the truly afflicted
Post Reply
User avatar
Martin Lo
Elite Angler
Elite Angler
Posts: 572
Joined: Mon Jun 30, 2014 9:26 pm

'15 Shimano Aldebaran take down and testing.

Post by Martin Lo » Sun Aug 02, 2015 12:09 am

The Lightweight King - Shimano 2015 Aldebaran 51 HG review.

Like the Exsence DC, my guess is there’ll be a review by TackleTour on the Aldebaran 2015 in the future, hence I’ll depart from the article style report and narrow it down to key points relevant to anglers in this review.

Image
This is one for the Shimano rep bragging points. Officially stated to be 135g on the scales it just under at 133.5 or under 4.7oz.

With a magnesium frame, carbon reinforced plastic for the both side plates the ’15 Aldebaran retains an alloy handle, dragstar, tension cap and rubber knobs similar to previous shimano septon albeit thinner in profile.

Image

On the palm plate is the plate locking latch and the SVS control dial which like the Metanium has marked increments from 1-6 but doesn’t click into each setting making it easy to fine tune in detail.

Image
Opening up reveals the SVS braking system, Shimano’s iteration of the flying arm centrifugal brake design. This time with 4 brakes.

Image
Like the current Metanium the clutch can be re-engaged by lifting the thumbar much like Daiwas.

Image
A large tapered line guide sits further away from the spool compared to the norm, this is consistent with current generation Shimano LP casting reels. Currently in industry there are a multitude of line guide shapes and naturally each brand claims their own as game changing, however along with TWS by Daiwa only this configuration of tapered guide plus extended distance visibly produces lower line angles as line peels off. It is this reduction in line angle that produces tangible improvements to casting distance of reels from both camps.

Image
Like the Aldebaran XG BFS and Calcutta Conquest the ’15 Aldebaran has a spool with a retained bearing. It also is the first feature of springs underneath both the spool bearing and the palm plate bearing. This Shimano has dubbed SilentTune. Together the whole spool assembly is 12g with capacity of 100m of 10lb reference monofilament.
Image
Without casting, it functions to centre the spool regardless of spool tension even with ample side play on the spool.

Image
Taking the reel apart further, underneath the cast aluminium dragstar is a wave spring as seen before in the ’13 Metanium and Saltiga Expedition. These springs can generate the same force with less spring height resulting in full open drag to full lock in under one complete turn of the drag and less effort locking down the last few clicks to full drag.

Image
The handle side plate is secured by 5 screws, 2 regular sized 3 much thinner ones than previous models. Note only one main screw goes into the alloy frame with the other 4 going from the frame to the CRP sideplate, differences in threads on the screws can be seen.

Image
The main gear comprised of Aluminium alloy, with conventional sized gearing and Dartanium outer/ Carbontex inner drag washers. Drag is smooth throughout the range of drag pressure.

Image
A departure from previous Shimanos, the clutch trip linkage rather than being a solid alloy piece is now a plastic linkage with attached alloy reinforcement.

Image
A bearing in the handle side plate underneath the tension cap. Ball bearings, like reel weight can often be just another marketing quality however this one and the another in the frame is one that sets Shimano and Daiwa reels apart from the also rans, the two bearings support the pinion gear, a small gear that spins as fast as the spool on retrieve, is required to shift along its axis (to disengage spool) and often placed under considerable strain. This keeps the gears meshed with closer tolerances and less friction under load.

Other details,
Image
Like the Metanium HG the Aldebaran HG has a 85mm bent handle with 2 bearings per knob. Unlike the Metanium the knobs are smaller and no longer distinguish from a left hand or right hand retrieve.

On the water

Given its weight and speed I opted to test the Aldebaran HG as part of a jerk bait setup. Paired with a Phenix M1 6’9”ML casting rod and 14lb Sunline Sniper FC I casted a variety of baits including the Rapala BXM10, Megabass Vision 110 and at on stage a Imakatsu Javallon 110 unweighted.

Image
A light powerful reel with a light powerful rod. Under 8.6oz with line.

Besides the obvious benefits of a lightweight setup I found the spring loaded spool entering allowed me to dial the tension cap right down yet remain controllable. Tension off, 2 brakes on, SVS set at 3 on a great loading rod I was able to cast medium distances with methods usually reserved for much shorter casts. Placing jerkbaits up against vegetation at a rapid pace was effortless. Note on the video the close to complete absence of sound during the cast, again very similar to the Metanium’s SVS brakes and among the best example of a centrifugal braking system. Together with the shallower spool and reduced line angle through the level wind the Aldebaran makes for a formidable finesse reel.

On the subject of retrieve, although I have not used resistance baits more than a 6’ crank thus far, sensations whilst cranking under load is unique. Being a magnesium reel with plastic side plates it did feel unavoidably hollow in hand, however at no point did the retrieve felt laboured or hesitant. and after several hours of use I surmise its a reel that works great even though first impression doesn't feel great on the retrieve.

Perhaps this section is best described as a short clip:

http://youtu.be/i9NbhGk-gOA


Against the field.

The Aldebaran does sit amongst incumbent competitors and in some ways they are some obvious similarities.



From its rival compatriot comes the SS SV now rebranded as the US Steez, at around $400 USD, it is also a Mg framed reel with CRP side plates, an effective easy casting SV brake system with similar capacity, the finesse Daiwa also benefits a double bearing supported pinion (Daiwas has long had this, Shimano just gave the bearing a name) weighing in at 150g/5.3oz.
Image

For $480USD is the Concept KP, again a Mg frame with CRP side plates, Weighs in at 5.03oz/145g line capacity 12lb/80m. With the trick shop it has access to a variety of factory coloured parts, and now in 2015 it has add features such as left hand wind variants plus a sideplate that hinged on the reel for easier brake adjustments.
Image

Now the Ald yet again an Mg frame, CRP side plates costing $420 USD it has a series of tangible improvements from its spool aligment springs, SVS system allowing for on the fly fine changes and fine tuning of the brakes, like the SS/Steez it’s “X-ship” means it’s also equipped with a double bearing supported pinion, holds 80m of 12lb FC, at <135g its also lighter than the next lightest reel by over 10g. It might not be the prettiest reel out there but its performance makes it a contender.
Image

Pen3
Pro Angler
Pro Angler
Posts: 2084
Joined: Fri May 25, 2007 2:23 pm
Location: Hopkins, Minnesota

Re: '15 Shimano Aldebaran take down and testing.

Post by Pen3 » Sun Aug 02, 2015 1:51 am

How do you compare it to the old Alde MG or a tuned Alde MG? There are still many that prefer the previous generation because of less flex, tons of aftermarket parts, and brass gear availability. All my rods are fancy JDM so the extra weight of the previous is also more desirable in pairing. It looks like you need a custom just to get a decent balance point for the '15. It might be just me of course :doh:

As for calling the new Steez an SS, we can't really tell till it is confirmed or did i miss something? The Steez limited are mg body with CRP sides and i have 3 of them. They are as much Steez as the old. I think it all comes down to how the tolerance will be on the new Steez and drag stack. If the tolerance is that of the SS then we can call it that, but if it feels like the Steez limited, then it is a Steez.

IAY
Platinum Angler
Platinum Angler
Posts: 1152
Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2014 9:28 am

Re: '15 Shimano Aldebaran take down and testing.

Post by IAY » Sun Aug 02, 2015 2:42 am

Comprehensive and detailed as always! =D> =D> Thanks for the review Martin.
Pen3 wrote:
As for calling the new Steez an SS, we can't really tell till it is confirmed or did i miss something? The Steez limited are mg body with CRP sides and i have 3 of them. They are as much Steez as the old. I think it all comes down to how the tolerance will be on the new Steez and drag stack. If the tolerance is that of the SS then we can call it that, but if it feels like the Steez limited, then it is a Steez.

I think it comes down to the gearing of Steez vs SS. They both have similar type of build material, but the Steez gear far surpasses the SS SV in terms of connectivity. I think the Steez on the new USDM 400 dollar models would be close to the Steez LTDs, at least I hope [-o<

Pen3
Pro Angler
Pro Angler
Posts: 2084
Joined: Fri May 25, 2007 2:23 pm
Location: Hopkins, Minnesota

Re: '15 Shimano Aldebaran take down and testing.

Post by Pen3 » Sun Aug 02, 2015 3:07 am

Well the 2015 trend for Daiwa is lowering their prices probably due to exchange rate and competition. Their Steez rods are more affordable, Zillion, Alphas, and J braid are also much cheaper. So i don't see why they wouldn't drop the price on the Steez.

Pen3
Pro Angler
Pro Angler
Posts: 2084
Joined: Fri May 25, 2007 2:23 pm
Location: Hopkins, Minnesota

Re: '15 Shimano Aldebaran take down and testing.

Post by Pen3 » Sun Aug 02, 2015 5:48 am

Wait, the '15 Alde comes with Carbontex, but the Metanium doesn't? I got ripped off with the Met than :crying:

User avatar
the hooligan
Pro Angler
Pro Angler
Posts: 1751
Joined: Sat Sep 01, 2012 11:25 am
Location: South Jersey

Re: '15 Shimano Aldebaran take down and testing.

Post by the hooligan » Sun Aug 02, 2015 8:11 am

Nice review Marty

User avatar
Bootytrain
Pro Angler
Pro Angler
Posts: 2449
Joined: Fri Mar 29, 2013 8:28 am

Re: '15 Shimano Aldebaran take down and testing.

Post by Bootytrain » Sun Aug 02, 2015 8:29 am

Nice break down and review as usual =D> I have the old Aldebaran and the SS SV. I prefer the new Alde over both. This reel is solid and noticeably smoother than the old adlebaran, the handle tolerance is much better and much lighter so cranking is pretty effortless. Palms better than both, casts a little better than both. I was not impressed with the SS SV with heavier weights. I hope the inductor is not stuck. I cant wait for the BFS version of the Aldebaran.

User avatar
Martin Lo
Elite Angler
Elite Angler
Posts: 572
Joined: Mon Jun 30, 2014 9:26 pm

Re: '15 Shimano Aldebaran take down and testing.

Post by Martin Lo » Sun Aug 02, 2015 3:31 pm

Bootytrain wrote:Nice break down and review as usual =D> I have the old Aldebaran and the SS SV. I prefer the new Alde over both. This reel is solid and noticeably smoother than the old adlebaran, the handle tolerance is much better and much lighter so cranking is pretty effortless. Palms better than both, casts a little better than both. I was not impressed with the SS SV with heavier weights. I hope the inductor is not stuck. I cant wait for the BFS version of the Aldebaran.
Yes this reel is a dead ringer for either a super shallow spool and most probably ZPI will come up with some form mag brake that can be dialed in with the SVS dial. Having to buy an entire spool assembly to get a hold of the brake holder is a bit of a downer however.

User avatar
Martin Lo
Elite Angler
Elite Angler
Posts: 572
Joined: Mon Jun 30, 2014 9:26 pm

Re: '15 Shimano Aldebaran take down and testing.

Post by Martin Lo » Tue Aug 04, 2015 1:35 am

Pen3 wrote:Wait, the '15 Alde comes with Carbontex, but the Metanium doesn't? I got ripped off with the Met than :crying:
Met's got carbon. One carbon cloth and one dartanium I think. In the end its smooth stock, so I don't think too much about it.

Pen3
Pro Angler
Pro Angler
Posts: 2084
Joined: Fri May 25, 2007 2:23 pm
Location: Hopkins, Minnesota

Re: '15 Shimano Aldebaran take down and testing.

Post by Pen3 » Tue Aug 04, 2015 3:44 am

Martin Lo wrote:
Pen3 wrote:Wait, the '15 Alde comes with Carbontex, but the Metanium doesn't? I got ripped off with the Met than :crying:
Met's got carbon. One carbon cloth and one dartanium I think. In the end its smooth stock, so I don't think too much about it.
Nope i just changed mine 2 days ago to Carbontex and both were Dartanium.

User avatar
Bootytrain
Pro Angler
Pro Angler
Posts: 2449
Joined: Fri Mar 29, 2013 8:28 am

Re: '15 Shimano Aldebaran take down and testing.

Post by Bootytrain » Tue Aug 04, 2015 5:15 am

Pen3 wrote:
Martin Lo wrote:
Pen3 wrote:Wait, the '15 Alde comes with Carbontex, but the Metanium doesn't? I got ripped off with the Met than :crying:
Met's got carbon. One carbon cloth and one dartanium I think. In the end its smooth stock, so I don't think too much about it.
Nope i just changed mine 2 days ago to Carbontex and both were Dartanium.
I believe shimano started using the cross carbon drags starting with the chronarch ci4 or curado I, so any reels before them didn't have it.

User avatar
Martin Lo
Elite Angler
Elite Angler
Posts: 572
Joined: Mon Jun 30, 2014 9:26 pm

Re: '15 Shimano Aldebaran take down and testing.

Post by Martin Lo » Tue Aug 04, 2015 9:46 am

Bootytrain wrote:
Pen3 wrote:
Martin Lo wrote:
Pen3 wrote:Wait, the '15 Alde comes with Carbontex, but the Metanium doesn't? I got ripped off with the Met than :crying:
Met's got carbon. One carbon cloth and one dartanium I think. In the end its smooth stock, so I don't think too much about it.
Nope i just changed mine 2 days ago to Carbontex and both were Dartanium.
I believe shimano started using the cross carbon drags starting with the chronarch ci4 or curado I, so any reels before them didn't have it.
I right...haha I serviced mine not a week ago and can't remember ](*,) ](*,)

Post Reply