- Elite Angler
- Posts: 423
- Joined: Fri Aug 20, 2004 11:50 am
- Location: 1313 Mockingbird Lane, Death Valley, CA 90210-->Now via Indiana
- Platinum Angler
- Posts: 1210
- Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 10:00 pm
- Location: Townsville , Queensland , Australia
Magnetic reels brake right down the the last spool revolution where centrifugal reels have very little braking happening. Centrifugal reels with very light weight baits have difficulty controlling the spool and will backlash as the baits slow. I would shoot a bait out there with my UL capable centrifugal Haibo Smart and all would be well until the end of the cast where I suddenly would fine the spool over running on me. Baits that carried their momentum well did just fine but once I got well below 1/8 oz total weight the spool would over run at the end of the cast because the tiny baits slowed so much at the end. That reel also has a magnetic 2nd brake and turning that up solved the issue. For bass baits I think centrifugal is fine but if you want the tiny trout stuff you'll find that reels designed for that have magnetic brake spools. The reasoning being that that braking profile does a better job at controlling the spool when casting these baits and is a bit lighter too.
It's the opposite of casting a compact bait heavy bait where you want a free braking profile to allow the bait to really fly unhindered. With the teeny tiny UL baits they shoot off fast from the rod tip then very rapppily slow with air resistance. You want a braking profile that can apply braking all the way to the bait hitting the water. Something that will smoothly brake all the way to the last spool rotation to control the spool to match it to the bait. Fixed inductor Daiwa or linear magnetic braking does exactly this.
- Hobie-Wan Kenobi
- Pro Angler
- Posts: 3009
- Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2014 1:25 pm
- Location: Michigan (U.P)
Shimano FTB doesn't require external inductor / added mass. But Air Daiwa's Air inductor doesn't add too much inertia.flipper502 wrote: ↑Tue Jun 28, 2022 12:34 pmFor BFS it's about the added weight of the brake assembly on the spool, especially important as you approach the outside diameter. That's also why BFS tend to use smaller diameter spools to minimize the inertia of not only the spool but the mass of line around it.
It's the braking profile. Magnetic brakes has linear brake curve, with exception of slowest revolution, where it goes asymptotically to 0. https://www.irjet.net/archives/V3/i4/IRJET-V3I4160.pdf Centrifugal brakes has exponentially growing brake curve.
I don't have apart BFS Daiwa inductor, so I weighted SV inductor which I have apart. It weights 1,6 g. So I think Air reels inductor weights something 0,8 g. Air spool with line weights 10 g. Inductor diameter is 18 mm. Spool (with line) mass centrum diameter is something 26 mm.BARRAMANIAC wrote: ↑Sat Jun 04, 2022 4:10 pmI am a Daiwa Fanboy when it comes to bait cast gear. But Shimanos FTB system seems to be the best for finesse. the Shimano system has removed all unnecessary weight from the spool to make the spools as light as possible for less start up inertia, a centrifugal system has to have that weight on the spool and the Daiwa magforce system adds weight to the spool due to the inductor cup.
0,8/10 x (18/26)^2 = 0,038.
Inductor plays ~4% role of spool rotational inertia.
So thinking how much this is...Inertia shrinks by 4% if taking inductor off. Same effect to inertia is if 10 g spool lightens to 9,6 g.
I have a Yumeya spool Scorpion XT 1000. For that range of baits centrifugal really does excel in distance especially with 1/20 to 1/7 oz head ned rigs that cast like darts. The super UL stuff that floats down to the ground? Not so much. I prefer the magnetic and especially linear magnetic brake BFS reels for that.rcdemel wrote: ↑Mon Dec 05, 2022 2:53 amAnother centrifugal brake fan here. I just got in to the BFS game about a year ago and am having a blast. While I do appreciate the magnetic braking system on my Alphas and Curado BFS reels, I find the old Shimano centrifugal brake system is a lot less finicky to use plus I pick up extra casting distance with most of the baits I throw (generally 3-4 grams). I have several older Curado 50Es and their Scorpion counterparts that I added Avail shallow spools to, and they perform perfectly fine for my applications.
In many ways...but I LOVE it.
I like Shimano's FTB. I have Scorpion BFS. I like, very good reel. It do what it should do.
I have a couple Daiwa's. I am not so pleased about moving induktor. Especially SV spool AIR-induktor ON/OFF-movement. Mag-Z is great. 3D gives allready too much adjustments :-D
BUT back to the brakes:
"Best" brake, the FTB brake is so complex to understand :-) That our china friends don't understand, when make reel right/left handed, have to change brakeassembly too.
But hey! I have used all summer copyreel with not working FTB. (letf hand Black knight II).
After that...I am not sure how much is needed...adjusting brake force in BFS :-D